Cards Against Supernatural: 355 Cards of Dark Humor

Cards Against Supernatural turns the show’s dark humor, monsters, characters, and iconic moments into a Cards Against Humanity-style game for ages 17+.

The deck includes 355 cards with references to Dean Winchester, Sam Winchester, demonic possession, monster hunting, wendigos, and more. Each round, the Card Czar reads a black card, while everyone else submits the funniest white response.

This unofficial digital PDF is an affordable pick for Supernatural fans who want a darker, funnier game night.

Card Examples Of CAH Supernatural

Want a sneak peek before getting the full deck? Here are a few Cards Against Supernatural cards to give you a taste of the humor.

 

 

 

What could Sam be crying about? Is his emotional side out?

Well, the possibilities of McGonagall transforming are endless…

This Pick 2 card could definitely bring outstanding, dirty responses. We’re here for that!

Black cards:

• This season Dean must overcome his fear of__________ to save the day.
• When I was tripping on dream root, __________turned into___________.
• What left this stain on the Impala?
• What is the third trial to close the gates of Hell?
• What is literally worse than Satan?
• _______.tumblr.com.
• Are you sure? ‘Cause Mr. Fizzles thinks you’re_________.
• Dean, I swear! Despite its name, _________is NOT a porno!
• Demons smell like sulfur; Angels smell like_________.
• In return for my soul Crowley promised me________, but all I got was________.

White cards:

• A butt thing.
• A bunch of people making up Supernatural card ideas because they have nothing better to do.
• Bees?
• The heart of a child.
• The homoerotic subtext of Supernatural.
• Teaching an angel to love.
• Taking a sharpie to the Mark of Cain and making it look like a penis.
• Vehemently denying that Tessa was anything but a reaper.
• Whore of Babylon
• The pure terror on Sam’s face while he’s covered head-to-toe in glitter!

Enjoy the game, you supernatural people!